FAQ  •  Register  • 
  • Login
  • Wireless Type Question

    <<

    TarHeelDead

    User avatar

    Respected Member
    Respected Member

    Posts: 336

    Joined: Tue Jul 27, 2010

    Location: Youngsville, NC

    Division: Battlefield 3

    Reputation: 0

    Post Fri Nov 05, 2010 4:49 pm

    Wireless Type Question

    Is there really a difference between using a PCI wireless card vs a PCI express card?

    I'm going to need to use wireless over Christmas break and maybe next summer as well since my parents house isn't the newest (so it doesn't have ethernet connections in rooms and the cable only comes in downstairs from my room). I can't just run a ethernet cable up to my desktop or anything like that so my only option is to use wireless. In my old desktop at the house I used a pci wireless card and it ran great but now that its a couple years later and pci express is easily available. I have both types of slots open in my desktop.

    For example what I'm glancing at:
    pci express: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16833166063
    pci: http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16833340013
    • 0

    CPU: i5-760 (stock w/turbo boost) RAM: 2x2GB G.SKILL Ripjaw 1333MHz (7-7-7-21) Video Card: XFX 5770 1GB HD: WD Black 1TB, WD Blue 500GB PSU: OCZ Modstream Pro 600W Screen: HANNS-G 20 in HDMI
    Image
    <<

    ThrillaKilla

    User avatar

    Honored Member
    Honored Member

    Posts: 777

    Joined: Sun Oct 3, 2010

    Division: Bad Company 2

    Reputation: 0

    Post Fri Nov 05, 2010 8:50 pm

    Re: Wireless Type Question

    either card should work fine... although the pci-ex card supports 802.11N which is faster if you ever plan have a router that supports 802.11N in the future. I'm assuming your parent's only have a 802.11b/g router so the pci-ex 802N card gives you no performance advantage over the pci 802g card.

    Ethernet is always better but as long as no one else is doing a lot of traffic (big download/upload) on the wifi you should be fine.
    • 0

    Image
    ImageImage
    <<

    ME.

    User avatar

    Esteemed Member
    Esteemed Member

    Posts: 1338

    Joined: Thu Aug 6, 2009

    Division: Half-Life 2 Deathmatch

    Reputation: 0

    Post Fri Nov 05, 2010 9:00 pm

    Re: Wireless Type Question

    Never used either Brand, but DLink is my favourite.
    Umm... it shouldn't make too much of a difference between PCI and PCI-E.
    I think PCI-E is a bit faster, but PCI will do just fine because there isn't enough data passing by to bottleneck anything.
    And newer MOBOs don't have PCI slots. So if you plan to keep this for a while, get a PCI-E, but if you plan to use this riht now and use it on an older computer later, get PCI.
    • 0

    ImageImage
    Sometimes measuring the bottleneck can be interpreted in so many ways. The only Thing ATI can render better then Nvidia is BSoD.
    <<

    TarHeelDead

    User avatar

    Respected Member
    Respected Member

    Posts: 336

    Joined: Tue Jul 27, 2010

    Location: Youngsville, NC

    Division: Battlefield 3

    Reputation: 0

    Post Fri Nov 05, 2010 10:47 pm

    Re: Wireless Type Question

    ThrillaKilla wrote:either card should work fine... although the pci-ex card supports 802.11N which is faster if you ever plan have a router that supports 802.11N in the future. I'm assuming your parent's only have a 802.11b/g router so the pci-ex 802N card gives you no performance advantage over the pci 802g card.

    Ethernet is always better but as long as no one else is doing a lot of traffic (big download/upload) on the wifi you should be fine.

    They are actually both N cards, the labeling just says B/G and draft N. I do have a N router myself that I'll be setting up as well (cause my parents do only have a G router which is all they need). But yeah, I'll pretty much be the only one using the wireless.

    ME. wrote:And newer MOBOs don't have PCI slots. So if you plan to keep this for a while, get a PCI-E, but if you plan to use this riht now and use it on an older computer later, get PCI.

    I don't normally change equipment over to new builds since I don't try to update every year, just every 3-4 yrs. I do have a brand new build actually that does have regular pci slots since I didn't go crazy expensive on my mobo but just in case I do need it later on in a different computer, I guess it would just make sense to get the pci-e card.
    • 0

    CPU: i5-760 (stock w/turbo boost) RAM: 2x2GB G.SKILL Ripjaw 1333MHz (7-7-7-21) Video Card: XFX 5770 1GB HD: WD Black 1TB, WD Blue 500GB PSU: OCZ Modstream Pro 600W Screen: HANNS-G 20 in HDMI
    Image
    <<

    ME.

    User avatar

    Esteemed Member
    Esteemed Member

    Posts: 1338

    Joined: Thu Aug 6, 2009

    Division: Half-Life 2 Deathmatch

    Reputation: 0

    Post Fri Nov 05, 2010 11:29 pm

    Re: Wireless Type Question

    Get PCI-E then :P :icon_teeth:
    • 0

    ImageImage
    Sometimes measuring the bottleneck can be interpreted in so many ways. The only Thing ATI can render better then Nvidia is BSoD.
    <<

    ThrillaKilla

    User avatar

    Honored Member
    Honored Member

    Posts: 777

    Joined: Sun Oct 3, 2010

    Division: Bad Company 2

    Reputation: 0

    Post Sun Nov 07, 2010 5:25 am

    Re: Wireless Type Question

    oh true, i missed that about the PCI card... if you have an N router and a mobo with a free PCI-E slot then PCI-e is the way to go since the price diff is negligible. PCI is prettymuch being phased out on new mobos anyways.
    • 0

    Image
    ImageImage
    <<

    (TKC) brownman350

    User avatar

    Exalted Member
    Exalted Member

    Posts: 4799

    Joined: Wed Jul 8, 2009

    Location: Canada

    Division: WarZ

    Steam Name: (TKC) brownman350

    BF3 Soldier: brownman350

    Reputation: 2

    Post Sun Nov 07, 2010 5:18 pm

    Re: Wireless Type Question

    True. :)
    ThrillaKilla wrote: PCI is prettymuch being phased out on new mobos anyways.
    • 0

    Image
    <<

    TarHeelDead

    User avatar

    Respected Member
    Respected Member

    Posts: 336

    Joined: Tue Jul 27, 2010

    Location: Youngsville, NC

    Division: Battlefield 3

    Reputation: 0

    Post Sun Nov 07, 2010 9:15 pm

    Re: Wireless Type Question

    ok, I'll probably stick with the pci-e version then. thanks
    • 0

    CPU: i5-760 (stock w/turbo boost) RAM: 2x2GB G.SKILL Ripjaw 1333MHz (7-7-7-21) Video Card: XFX 5770 1GB HD: WD Black 1TB, WD Blue 500GB PSU: OCZ Modstream Pro 600W Screen: HANNS-G 20 in HDMI
    Image

    Return to General Discussion

    Who is online

    Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests

    cron
    x

    #{title}

    #{text}